"From the Oscar-winning producer of Man on Wire and Emmy-winning producer of LA 92" comes
Sophie: A Murder in West Cork. This docuseries directed by John Dower. This three-part series examines one of Ireland’s most famous murder cases, the death of French producer Sophie Toscan du Plantier in the town of Schull, West Cork in 1996. The brutal murder, which shocked the country, triggered one of the biggest murder investigations Ireland had ever seen and became a national obsession. The documentary will chart the circumstances of her death, unravelling the extraordinary story from its beginning, twenty-four years ago to the present day. With exclusive access to Sophie Toscan du Plantier’s family, the series will bring together, for the first time, the views of her family with Ian Bailey, the man at the centre of the investigation.
On the night of 23 December 1996, thirty-nine year old French television producer, Sophie Toscan du Plantier, was killed outside her holiday home near Toormore, Goleen, County Cork, Ireland. British journalist Ian Bailey was arrested twice by the Garda Síochána, yet no charges were laid as the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) found there was insufficient evidence to proceed to trial. In 2003, Bailey lost a libel case against six newspapers. In 2015, he also lost a wrongful arrest case against the Gardaí, minister for Justice, and Attorney General. In 2019, Bailey was convicted of murder by the Cour d'Assises de Paris and sentenced to twenty-five years in prison. He was tried in absentia in France after winning a legal battle against extradition. In 2020, Ireland's High Court ruled that Bailey could not be extradited.
A fascinating true-crime documentary that is as perplexing in its mystery as it is entertaining in its execution. Dower wisely knows that he's not going to solve this case that even the Irish authorities couldn't crack, and instead broadens his perspective into what the case means to people and why this unsolved mystery has such enduring power. This story from Dower picks apart what became a murder story and hears from retired Irish policemen involved the in case, and the friends and family members of a handful of suspects. I was left with two thoughts: evidence, without any additional motive or context, is not as it says; and all people want to be, briefly, acknowledged for their life, preferably on screen. Puts the known facts and a collection of the best theories through their paces over a somewhat overdrawn three-hours. Dower's documentary is simply content to revel in the unknowability of its story. To that end, it's a tantalizing look at a case that stymies conclusions at every turn. A fascinating look at the people who still, so many years later, insist on sharing their truth. Maybe the best part of the whole thing is this: Only one of them (if any) can be right, but it's easy to believe them all. However, with so much material, it's hard to steer the narrative. The series skillfully sketches out the details of the crime without fully capturing what makes the case so appealing to obsessives.
Simon says Sophie: A Murder in West Cork receives:
No comments:
Post a Comment